Reviews

Nothing makes us happier than happy patients.

See what families like yours have to say about our dental care.

Review Summary

5   324
4   10
3   2
2   0
1   0
13 reviews with no rating
5.0
349 reviews
5 on Google, Sep 01, 2026
an absolutely wonderful experience. great people and service.
Practice Response:
Thanks for taking the time to leave a review! Our staff is encouraged by these words.
5 on Google, Aug 28, 2026
Practice Response:
Thank you for a great rating!
5 on Our Website, Aug 24, 2026
Dr. McKibben was professional and personable. His demeanor put me at ease and his work is top notch. I’m so happy with my smile now!!
Practice Response:
Hearing back from our patients is really important to us, so we deeply appreciate the feedback. Thank you for taking the time to share with us, and have a wonderful day!
5 on Google, Aug 20, 2026
Practice Response:
Thank you! We love hearing from patients who are happy with our care and services!
5 on Google, Aug 19, 2026
I went to mckibben dental for the first time yesterday and i was very happy with the entire experience. All of the personnel, from the receptionist to the hygienist to the dentist were exceptionally friendly and welcoming. They were very thorough and i felt like i was in very good hands. I am... more »
Practice Response:
Great oral health care is all about our commitment to our patients, to their comfort, and to their experience in our office. Thanks for showing our community that we aim to make all our patients happier and healthier!
5 on Our Website, Aug 18, 2026
Awesome, very educational experience there I loved every bit of my appointment everyone was so nice & welcoming 😉
Practice Response:
We strive to be a dental care provider of choice. Thank you for sharing!
5 on Our Website, Aug 18, 2026
Wendy cleaned my teeth thoroughly (hand scaled around each tooth), which I appreciate (and expect from hygienists). She and Dr. Ehrbar are very nice and make it a pleasurable experience!
Practice Response:
Thanks for taking the time to leave a review! Our staff is encouraged by these words.
5 on Google, Aug 18, 2026
Practice Response:
We appreciate you taking the time out of your day to rate our team!
5 on Google, Aug 18, 2026
Practice Response:
Thank you for the input on how we are achieving our patient satisfaction goals. We appreciate it!
5 on Our Website, Aug 17, 2026
As always, the staff was outstanding! Jen always does a terrific job with the teeth cleaning, and doing the X-rays I was due to get for this visit. . Diane Ehrbar is an outstanding dentist who filled a small cavity that resulted from an old filling in my front upper tooth falling out, that I... more »
Practice Response:
Great oral health care is all about our commitment to our patients, to their comfort, and to their experience in our office. Thanks for showing our community that we aim to make all our patients happier and healthier!
5 on Google, Aug 15, 2026
Practice Response:
A positive review like this one makes our day! Thanks for spreading the word!
5 on Google, Aug 12, 2026
Practice Response:
Thank you for a great rating!
5 on Our Website, Aug 06, 2026
Procedure for new crown started. All went well. Staff is so efficient and affable. Except for my mouth being sore from having it open for some length of time the procedure was painless. Who ever said that going to the dentist is a painful experience?
Practice Response:
Reviews help our practice grow. Thank you so much for sharing a great one!
5 on Our Website, Aug 06, 2026
I was very pleased with the service as always. In addition, it was very educational. My hygienist took the time to explain everything she was doing and teach me how to better take care of my teeth. And the Doctor completed the day with more advice. . I truly appreciate the help of everyone involved... more »
Practice Response:
Our practice strives to provide an excellent experience for each patient, and we are excited to hear when we exceed expectations. We appreciate the kind review!
5 on Our Website, Aug 06, 2026
Staff is always helpful and courteous. They are thoughtful about your concerns and pay close attention to your needs regarding pain tolerance.
Practice Response:
We are thankful to treat our patients’ smiles with the utmost care every day. Please accept our sincerest gratitude for recommending our office.
5 on Google, Aug 05, 2026
First visit to doctor McKibben. I really enjoyed his thorough review and consultation. I looked forward to working closely with him to achieve my goals and smile makeover.
Practice Response:
Reviews help our practice grow. Thank you so much for sharing a great one!
5 on Google, Aug 04, 2026
Taken on time and everyone is very professional
Practice Response:
Our practice strives to provide an excellent experience for each patient, and we are excited to hear when we exceed expectations. We appreciate the kind review!
5 on Google, Jul 31, 2026
I absolutely LOVE Dr. EHRBAR and the staff that worked with me on yesterday! And I HIGHLY recommend my dentist Dr. EHRBAR she’s very personable, kind and gentle for us cowardly, fearful of the dentist types
Practice Response:
We are thankful to treat our patients’ smiles with the utmost care every day. Please accept our sincerest gratitude for recommending our office.
5 on Google, Jul 29, 2026
I went in as a terrified patient determined to do this "dental care" thing. Growing up It wasn't a priority in my family and I saw a lot of relatives pass away with very few teeth! From reception to Dr McKibben himself I felt cared for. Freda the hygienist was a gift from heaven I needed that... more »
Practice Response:
Thanks a lot for taking the time to provide us with feedback! We want to provide superior dental care, and this input helps our team in so many ways.
5 on Google, Jul 28, 2026
Office is ALWAYS accommodating for Consultations. Staff very friendly and caring.
Practice Response:
Thank you for reviewing our office. We appreciate the opportunity to treat our fantastic patients and we are grateful for the confidence in our team.

Request an Appointment

We are taking new patients in Reynoldsburg and the surrounding Columbus area. We offer a wide range of dentistry services, including regular dental cleanings and check-ups, fillings, root canals and crowns.

Our Location

Conveniently Located in Reynoldsburg

614-575-9530

7643 E Main St
Reynoldsburg, OH 43068

Hours:
Monday: 8:00 AM - 4:30 PM
Tuesday: 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Wednesday: 11:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Thursday: 8:00 AM - 4:30 PM
Friday: 8:00 AM - 3:00 PM


As a courtesy to our other patients, we kindly request two business days' notice before rescheduling.

Associations and Memberships

We’re proud to be affiliated with the following organizations:

ADA Black
ODA Grayscale
Spear Education Black

5-Star Patient Reviews