Reviews

Nothing makes us happier than happy patients.

See what families like yours have to say about our dental care.

Review Summary

5   271
4   8
3   2
2   0
1   0
12 reviews with no rating
5.0
293 reviews
5 on Google, Apr 07, 2026
Awesome care and friendly staff...thanks!
Practice Response:
Our practice strives to provide an excellent experience for each patient, and we are excited to hear when we exceed expectations. We appreciate the kind review!
5 on Google, Mar 28, 2026
Practice Response:
We appreciate you taking the time out of your day to rate our team!
5 on Google, Mar 24, 2026
Practice Response:
Thanks for the feedback. We are committed to every patient experience!
5 on Google, Mar 20, 2026
Doctor and staff are great and really care about their patients.
Practice Response:
We are thankful to treat our patients’ smiles with the utmost care every day. Please accept our sincerest gratitude for recommending our office.
5 on Google, Mar 17, 2026
At McKibben dental I am received with a smile and I leaved with a smile thank you guys for a job well done.
Practice Response:
Thanks a lot for taking the time to provide us with feedback! We want to provide superior dental care, and this input helps our team in so many ways.
5 on Google, Mar 17, 2026
Friendly staff. Very clean.
Practice Response:
Thank you for reviewing our office. We appreciate the opportunity to treat our fantastic patients and we are grateful for the confidence in our team.
5 on Google, Mar 16, 2026
Both my husband and me saw Dr Ehrbar for our dental checkup. We greatly appreciated her kindness and her pleasant attitude about giving us excellent dental care. I admit I present her with a real challenge and she works to come up with the best solution. Each dental hygienist that worked on us... more »
Practice Response:
We take pride in our services and treatment options, and we love to know when patients are pleased with the results. Thanks for sharing with us!
5 on Google, Mar 11, 2026
Always receive excellent care
Practice Response:
Hearing back from our patients is really important to us, so we deeply appreciate the feedback. Thank you for taking the time to share with us, and have a wonderful day!
5 on Google, Mar 11, 2026
Normally, I am deadly afraid of dentists, but not this one. Sweet, easy going, down to earth man. I trust him completely! Also, lovely ladies in the practice. Update on 3/10/26. Just had a temporary crown installed and I asked for "painless" numbing. I am petrified of needles! This dental doctor... more »
Practice Response:
Thank you so much for your kind words; we strive to put our patients at ease!
5 on Google, Mar 10, 2026
Place is clean, our family has been coming here for last 25 years. Our whole family goes here. When Dr Herring retired we were concerned but after meeting Dr McKibben we are gaining the trust that we had with Dr Herring. Dr McKibben so far has been nice, he listens and he seems to care about his... more »
Practice Response:
We strive to be a dental care provider of choice. Thank you for sharing!
5 on Google, Mar 06, 2026
Dr Craig and his practice was awesome! Our son had an accident and they got us in immediately and were wonderful with him. Very much appreciate them and would recommend them to anyone!
Practice Response:
Thanks for taking the time to leave a review! Our staff is encouraged by these words.
5 on Google, Mar 03, 2026
Top quality dental care from my dentist Dr. Diane Ehrbar and my hygienist Jen! I wouldn’t consider going anywhere else for dental work!
Practice Response:
Great oral health care is all about our commitment to our patients, to their comfort, and to their experience in our office. Thanks for showing our community that we aim to make all our patients happier and healthier!
5 on Google, Mar 03, 2026
Had a great cleaning on Monday. They found a bad filling got me back in on Thursday to replace it. Dr. Diane Ehrbar did a great job with Brittany assisting easy and efficient very professional. The whole experience from checking in to checking out, was very very professional, very friendly, and... more »
Practice Response:
Reviews help our practice grow. Thank you so much for sharing a great one!
5 on Google, Mar 02, 2026
Awesome experience
Practice Response:
Our practice strives to provide an excellent experience for each patient, and we are excited to hear when we exceed expectations. We appreciate the kind review!
5 on Google, Feb 27, 2026
Practice Response:
We are proud to provide our patients with the highest quality of dental care possible. This rating lets us know we are on the right track. Thanks!
5 on Google, Feb 24, 2026
The McKibben Dental hygienists and dentists are professionals I trust with my dental health. I’ve been elsewhere and felt that the practice was more interested in their bottom line than my dental health. Not at McKibben Dental however. I feel like they truly care.
Practice Response:
We are thankful to treat our patients’ smiles with the utmost care every day. Please accept our sincerest gratitude for recommending our office.
5 on Google, Feb 21, 2026
Practice Response:
Thank you for leaving a review! Our team aims to provide exemplary care for all of our amazing patients.
5 on Google, Feb 21, 2026
Great service. Good experiences.
Practice Response:
Thanks a lot for taking the time to provide us with feedback! We want to provide superior dental care, and this input helps our team in so many ways.
5 on Our Website, Feb 20, 2026
The staff is always very welcoming!
Practice Response:
Hearing back from our patients is really important to us, so we deeply appreciate the feedback. Thank you for taking the time to share with us, and have a wonderful day!
5 on Our Website, Feb 20, 2026
Saved me money by re lining my dentures. Did a great job!!
Practice Response:
We strive to be a dental care provider of choice. Thank you for sharing!

Request an Appointment

We are taking new patients in Reynoldsburg and the surrounding Columbus area. We offer a wide range of dentistry services, including regular dental cleanings and check-ups, fillings, root canals and crowns.

Our Location

Conveniently Located in Reynoldsburg

614-575-9530

7643 E Main St
Reynoldsburg, OH 43068

Hours:
Monday: 8:00 AM - 4:30 PM
Tuesday: 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Wednesday: 11:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Thursday: 8:00 AM - 4:30 PM
Friday: 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Saturday by appointment only


As a courtesy to our other patients, we kindly request two business days' notice before rescheduling.

Associations and Memberships

We’re proud to be affiliated with the following organizations:

ADA Black
ODA Grayscale
Spear Education Black

5-Star Patient Reviews